Fallacious rebuttal


Improve the ability to spot the fallacies


Your task is to identify the fallacy used in the refutation and provide a suitable response to address the fallacy.

In this exercise, you will be presented with a statement that contains a fallacy.


Follow these steps:

  1. Read and understand the given statement.
  2. Identify the fallacy used in the refutation.
  3. Clearly state the fallacy and explain why it is present in the refutation.
  4. Provide a suitable response that addresses the fallacy and presents a logical argument or counterargument.
  5. Support your response with evidence, reasoning, or counterarguments to demonstrate the flaw in the original refutation.
  6. Ensure your response is clear, concise, and effectively challenges the fallacy presented.
  7. Remember to focus on the fallacy used in the refutation and address it specifically in your response.


Some of the fallacies you can consider for this exercise are on this link:


Thou shalt not commit logical fallacies (yourlogicalfallacyis.com)


Some examples of statements that contain logical fallacies to do this exercise are:

  • "Since everyone is using smartphones these days, it must mean that smartphones are the best form of communication."
  • "If you don't support this policy, then you must be against progress and innovation."
  • "The majority of scientists agree that climate change is real, so it must be true."
  • "I have never seen a UFO, so I conclude that they don't exist."
  • "If you support this policy, you must hate the environment."